Scotch thistle can be controlled by mechanical, cultural, and chemical methods.Mechanical control is very effective if you do it before the plant goes to seed since they only reproduce by seed. Scotch thistle will germinate in nutrient deficient soils. Seeds remain viable for up to seven years and fall close to the plant but wind, water, wildlife, livestock, and human activities disperse the seed.
Using a combination of methods is best and revegetation after treatment is recommended. Planting competitive grasses helps prevent the invasion and establishment of new scotch thistle plants. Retreatment may be necessary for four to six years or until the seed bank in the soil is exhausted. Simply severing the roots of the rosette or plant kills it. Be careful though because the plant has stout spines.